Internal Buyouts

Use Case: Internal Buyouts

Many business owners eventually sell to someone inside the company, whether it be a co-owner, key employee, or family member. These internal deals often feel smoother and easier than going to market, and in many cases, they are.

But they can also become emotionally charged, loosely structured, or difficult to price fairly. These transitions tend to happen behind closed doors, often without third-party advisors. As a result, there’s a real risk of underpricing, resentment, or confusion about what the business is actually worth.

An independent valuation helps keep the process fair, professional, and well-documented while protecting relationships throughout the process.

‍

The Problem with “Handshake” Deals

Many internal buyouts start informally. A quick conversation turns into a plan, and before long, expectations are forming. Without a credible valuation, the deal risks being based on assumptions, informal math, or an owner’s gut feeling.

This may seem efficient at first, but it can create long-term problems. If the price is too low, the seller may regret it. If it’s too high, the buyer may struggle to finance or justify the deal, especially if the business doesn't perform as expected after the transition.

Bringing in a third-party valuation early helps avoid these issues. It provides neutral ground and a defensible starting point for the conversation.

‍

Why Internal Valuations Often Come in Lower

It’s important to recognize that internal buyouts tend to result in lower valuations than open-market sales. This isn’t always a red flag, and is more a reflection of how these deals work.

In an internal sale, there’s typically only one buyer. In a competitive external process, multiple buyers can bid against each other, and that demand drives up price. Without that competition, the value often reflects a more conservative, financially manageable structure.

In addition, the remaining team, especially if they’re financing the buyout, may be cautious about overcommitting. If the outgoing owner was a major contributor to profitability, their departure introduces risk. For this reason, internal valuations are often structured to reflect affordability, long-term sustainability, and lower transaction complexity.

This is exactly why a professional, market-based valuation is so helpful. It grounds the price in real-world comparables while still giving both sides room to structure the deal in a way that works for them.

‍

Avoid Conflict and Build Confidence

Internal transitions work best when everyone feels heard, respected, and fairly treated. A valuation helps:

- Prevent awkward negotiations between friends, colleagues, or family

- Create a pricing benchmark that advisors and lenders can support

- Reduce the chance of post-deal regret or conflict

- Set expectations for future involvement or phased transitions

Buyers gain peace of mind that they’re paying a fair amount for what they’re getting. Sellers gain confidence that they’re not underselling the business they’ve built.

‍

What We Recommend

For most internal buyouts, our Standard Package is the best fit. It includes a ~40-page valuation report using multiple methods, adjusted earnings, risk commentary, and relevant comparables. It’s detailed enough to support formal agreements and financing but still accessible to non-specialists.

If you’re early in the process or working through an informal handoff, like a partial buyout between partners or a first-step discussion with a junior team member, the Lite Package offers a concise, credible report that helps move things forward.

‍

Keep It Clear, Fair, and Professional

Selling your business to someone you know should be a smooth, rewarding process, not one that causes second-guessing or unnecessary friction. A neutral, third-party valuation helps everyone feel confident in the decision and strengthens the deal from day one.

You don’t need a broker or a public listing to treat your exit professionally. You just need the right foundation.

‍

Ready to Take the First Step?

We work with business owners, employees, and advisors to support internal transitions with clarity and care. See our pricing or contact us to talk through your situation and find the best fit.

‍